Moderation:Moderation Documents/Judgments/2024-08-23/yvan spamming: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 15:33, 11 September 2024

All dates and times in this document are in UTF+8.

yvan Sent multiple spam messages to the chat:

Time	Sender	Message
2024-08-23 23:15:26	yvan joined the game (new player)
(4 messages omitted)
2024-08-23 23:18:01	yvan	mjhjjjttttttttt
2024-08-23 23:18:10	y5nw	yvan: ?
(3 messages omitted)
2024-08-23 23:19:57	yvan	hjmghygtvjyduweirtujtfhjxkljmjketj,hfhncnužtfhjmiibkytmágukmhgyrjkkžoictkf.lftj.f,km
2024-08-23 23:20:12	HelenasaurusRex	Please don't do that.
(16 messages omitted)
2024-08-23 23:24:37	yvan	vvbvbbfvvnvbjnfjcj
2024-08-23 23:25:05	HelenasaurusRex	I think we should revoke now, do you? Ah
2023-08-23 23:28:16	yvan left the game (timed out)

(The times are taken from the Telegram bridge and may therefore be delayed. The above list includes all messages sent by yvan to the mt_main channel in the time period.)

y5nw revoked yvan's shout privilege between the last two chat messages listed above. The exact time could not be determined as it is not available in the chat bridge.

The revocation of the shout privilege was performed as a temporary measure based on the consideration that

The messages sent by the accused player had a negative impact on the order on the server (Moderation Team Rule 2.2). Specifically, the messages disturbed ongoing conversations between HelenasaurusRex and y5nw without bringing meaningful content to the chatroom (Rule 7);
The messages were sent without any explanation (y5nw: "yvan: ?");
The sender did not appear to have taken the disapproval of other players (HelenasaurusRex: "Please don't do that.") into consideration (Rule 1); and
While the performed measure does not fall under the scope of "kicking or banning any player" (Moderation Team Rule 4), it does significantly limit the ability of the accused player to interact with other players, which is not justifiable as a long-term measure given the relatively low severity of the actions of the accused player.

The following actions should be taken:

yvan should have shout revoked for the minimum period stopping their action.
- That is, by the time this document is written (2024-08-24 08:35:33), the privilege should be restored.

Email from y5nw to yvan

This is a mail send by y5nw to yvan.

Subject: Revocation of the shout privilege

Hello yvan,

your shout privilege has been revoked due to spamming, which is against
* Rule 1, as you continued writing after being asked to stop by HelenasaurusRex, and
* Rule 7: "No spamming".

The current measure taken against you is only temporary at the time of writing and will be reevaluated by other moderators.

It should additionally be noted that this incident will be taken into consideration for future punishments if you choose to break the rules again.

Sincerely,
y5nw

Follow-up email from 1F616EMO to yvan

This is a mail send by 1F616EMO to yvan.

Subject: More on the revocation of the shout privilege

Dear yvan,

Your shout privilege has been restored. You should not spam in the chatroom, including sending random characters, as that disturbs communications between other players.

Yours truly,
1F616EMO

Detailed judgement can be found at: https://wiki-twi.1f616emo.xyz/s/B

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-On 2024-08-23, at 23:18:00, {{P|yvan}} started spamming random characters. {{P|HelenasaurusRex}} asked them to stop at 23:20:11, and at the same time, {{P|y5nw}} suggested revoking {{P|yvan|nolink=1}}'s <code>shout</code> privilege. They continued to spam until 23:24:36, when {{P|y5nw|nolink=1}} revoked their <code>shout</code> privilege. {{P|y5nw|nolink=1}} sent a mail to {{P|yvan|nolink=1}} about this decision at 23:34:14. Eventually, {{P|yvan|nolink=1}} left due to timing out at 02:26:03.
+''All dates and times in this document are in UTF+8.''
+{{P|yvan}} Sent multiple spam messages to the chat:
+{| class="wikitable"
+! Time !! Sender !! Message
+|-
+| 2024-08-23 23:15:26 || colspan=2 | ''yvan joined the game (new player)''
+|-
+| colspan=3 | ''(4 messages omitted)''
+|-
+| 2024-08-23 23:18:01 || yvan || mjhjjjttttttttt
+|-
+| 2024-08-23 23:18:10 || y5nw || yvan: ?
+|-
+| colspan=3 | ''(3 messages omitted)''
+|-
+| 2024-08-23 23:19:57 || yvan || hjmghygtvjyduweirtujtfhjxkljmjketj,hfhncnužtfhjmiibkytmágukmhgyrjkkžoictkf.lftj.f,km
+|-
+| 2024-08-23 23:20:12 || HelenasaurusRex || Please don't do that.
+|-
+| colspan=3 | ''(16 messages omitted)''
+|-
+| 2024-08-23 23:24:37 || yvan || vvbvbbfvvnvbjnfjcj
+|-
+| 2024-08-23 23:25:05 || HelenasaurusRex || I think we should revoke now, do you? Ah
+|-
+| 2023-08-23 23:28:16 || colspan=2 | ''yvan left the game (timed out)''
+|}
+''(The times are taken from the Telegram bridge and may therefore be delayed. The above list includes all messages sent by yvan to the <code>mt_main</code> channel in the time period.)''
+y5nw revoked yvan's shout privilege between the last two chat messages listed above. The exact time could not be determined as it is not available in the chat bridge.
+The revocation of the shout privilege was performed as a temporary measure based on the consideration that
+* The messages sent by the accused player had a negative impact on the order on the server (Moderation Team Rule 2.2). Specifically, the messages disturbed ongoing conversations between HelenasaurusRex and y5nw without bringing meaningful content to the chatroom (Rule 7);
+* The messages were sent without any explanation (y5nw: "yvan: ?");
+* The sender did not appear to have taken the disapproval of other players (HelenasaurusRex: "Please don't do that.") into consideration (Rule 1); and
+* While the performed measure does not fall under the scope of "kicking or banning any player" (Moderation Team Rule 4), it does significantly limit the ability of the accused player to interact with other players, which is not justifiable as a long-term measure given the relatively low severity of the actions of the accused player.
 The following actions should be taken:
@@ Line 43: / Line 82: @@
 Detailed judgement can be found at: https://wiki-twi.1f616emo.xyz/s/B
 }}
+[[Category:Judgments for chat spam]]